Perceptions of homogeneity reproduction in health sciences academia
TL;DR
Who looks like they belong in academia, and who learns to make parts of themselves less visible?
Interviews with nine people at a German university hospital explored exclusion and pressure to fit an ideal academic: always available, mobile and productive. The possible cycle of exclusion is an interpretation to test.
What might someone have to hide to meet that ideal, and what would their institution need to change so they could stop?
Journal article
PLOS One · 2026 · 21(10), e0345194
Abstract
Academic institutions privilege norms of continuous productivity and uninterrupted availability, creating conformity pressures that systematically disadvantage those who deviate from an implicit template of the ‘ideal academic’. This study explores how doctoral students and faculty in the health sciences perceive the reproduction of social homogeneity. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with nine participants at a German university hospital. Data were analysed using reflexive thematic analysis with extended idiographic engagement. Participants perceived homogeneity as reproduced through external exclusion, enacted by others through networks, normative expectations, or institutional arrangements, and self-exclusion, whereby individuals withdrew, reduced visibility, or reshaped identity in anticipation of exclusion (‘anticipatory compliance’). Across both processes, the tacit norm of the ideal academic organised access and belonging. Supportive supervision and visible role models were perceived as partial buffers but did not structurally alter underlying norms. Interpreted through the social identity threat framework, these accounts support an exploratory interpretation of a possible self-reinforcing cycle: structural homogeneity may generate identity-threatening environments that activate concealment and withdrawal, potentially concentrating homogeneity further. These findings suggest that achieving substantive inclusion requires challenging the structural conditions that naturalise presence, mobility, and availability as measures of academic success.
Abstract reproduced from the published source · CC BY 4.0.
Cite this paper
Rieke Buckup; Jamie B. Smith; Gertraud Stadler; Pichit Buspavanich (2026). Perceptions of homogeneity reproduction in health sciences academia. PLOS One, 21(10), e0345194. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0345194
Publication: .
Available versions
- Publisher full text — Version of record. CC BY 4.0.